Fewer than 10 or 20 people

My Agency Has Fewer Than 10 (or 20) People. Do the Data Security Rules Apply to Me?

Updated November 11, 2026

Short answer: Partly. Under the NAIC's data security model law (#668), an agency with fewer than 10 employees, counting independent contractors, is exempt from the section that requires a written security program, but not from breach notice. The NAIC's safeguards model (#673) has no such exemption in its text, in our reading. In New York, an agency under 20 people may qualify for a limited exemption from 23 NYCRR 500, which still requires a written policy for vendors, a risk assessment and multi-factor authentication. So "we're small" narrows what you owe, but it rarely removes the need to vet the AI tools that hold your clients' information.

The #668 exemption: fewer than 10 people

Section 9A(1) of #668 says: "A Licensee with fewer than ten employees, including any independent contractors, is exempt from Section 4 of this Act" (NAIC #668).

Three details matter:

  • The count includes independent contractors. A five-person agency with six producers on contract is at 11, not 5.
  • It covers Section 4 only. Section 4 is the written information security program, including the vendor oversight duties in section 4F. Our reading is that the exemption names section 4 and nothing else.
  • It does not cover breach notice. Section 6 still applies, including the 72-hour notice to your home-state commissioner (and to another state's commissioner when the event involves "250 or more Consumers residing in this State" and meets further conditions), and the rule that a vendor's event is treated as the agency's own (section 6D). Under #668 your clock starts the day after the vendor tells you, or the day after you otherwise learn of the event, whichever is sooner.

So a small agency in a #668 state does not have to build the full written program, but it still needs to know when an AI vendor would tell it about a breach, because the notice duty is its own.

Covered by someone else's program. Section 9A(3) exempts "An employee, agent, representative or designee of a Licensee, who is also a Licensee" from Section 4 "to the extent that" it "is covered by the Information Security Program of the other Licensee." A captive agent working under a carrier's program is the usual example. The exemption reaches only as far as the other program actually covers you, so check what the carrier's program says about the AI tools you use.

Not every state adopted #668, and states that did may have changed it. The AI rules page lists the states the NAIC shows as adopters.

The safeguards rule (#673): no size exemption in its text

GLBA's safeguards duty reaches agencies through state rules, and the NAIC's template for those rules is #673 (NAIC #673). It asks each licensee to "implement a comprehensive written information security program ... appropriate to the size and complexity of the licensee", and gives, as its example of how to run that program, a licensee that "Exercises appropriate due diligence in selecting its service providers" (section 8). Check how your state's version words it.

Unlike #668, #673 has no fewer-than-10-employee exemption in its text, in our reading. It scales the program to the agency's size instead. So in a state with a #673-style rule, "we're under 10 people" is not a full answer: the program can be small, but it should exist and it should cover the AI vendor. Ask your counsel how your state's version reads.

New York: the 23 NYCRR 500 exemptions

New York's Department of Financial Services sets out its exemptions on its exemptions page, which we read on November 11, 2026. Entities with a full exemption "do not need to comply with any requirements of the Cybersecurity Regulation", and those with a limited exemption "need to comply with some requirements".

The small-entity limited exemption, section 500.19(a), has three tests. Meeting any one is enough:

  • the covered entity and its affiliates combined "have less than 20 employees and independent contractors"; or
  • "less than $7,500,000 in gross annual revenue in each of the last 3 fiscal years from all of its business operations, wherever located, and its Affiliates' New York business operations"; or
  • "less than $15,000,000 in year-end total assets."

What a limited-exempt agency must still do, according to the DFS page:

Still required Section
Cybersecurity program, in part 500.2(a), (b), (d) and (e)
Cybersecurity policy 500.3
Access privileges and management 500.7(a) and (b)
Risk assessment 500.9
Third-party service provider security policy 500.11
Multi-factor authentication 500.12
Asset management and data retention requirements 500.13
Cybersecurity awareness training 500.14(a)(3)
Notices to the superintendent 500.17

What it may skip includes encryption of nonpublic information (500.15) and the incident response and business continuity plans (500.16). A limited-exempt agency must "Submit a Notice of Exemption" and "Submit an annual compliance notification each year".

The line that matters most for AI is 500.11. Even a small New York agency needs a written policy for the security of client information "accessible to, or held by, third-party service providers" (23 NYCRR 500). An AI tool that stores your chats is one of those providers.

Two full exemptions agents ask about:

  • Agents fully covered by a carrier's program (500.19(b)). The agency "must be an employee, agent, wholly owned subsidiary, representative, or designee of another DFS-regulated business, and all aspects of the Covered Entity's business must be fully covered by the cybersecurity program of the other DFS-regulated business." Our reading is that if you use an AI tool the carrier's program does not cover, "all aspects" may no longer be true.
  • Inactive individual agents (500.19(g)). The exemption covers "an individual insurance agent placed in inactive status under Insurance Law Section 2103".

What a small agency should still do before using AI on client data

Whatever your size, the parts of the rules that survive the exemptions point to the same short list:

  1. Know your notice path. Find out how and when the AI vendor will tell you about a security event, because your notice duty survives the #668 exemption and the New York limited exemption.
  2. Vet the vendor. Read its training, retention and access terms on its own pages, and keep a copy. The vendor questionnaire is a starting point.
  3. Write it down. In a #673-style state, or in New York under 500.11, a short written policy that covers the AI tool is part of what is still required.
  4. Turn on multi-factor authentication for the AI tool if you are a New York agency, since 500.12 still applies to limited-exempt entities.
  5. Check whether a carrier's program covers you, and whether it covers the AI tools you use, before relying on a captive-agent exemption.

The small agency options page sets out what the self-serve plans keep and who can see it, which is most of what these steps ask you to find out.

This guide is general information, not legal or compliance advice. Exemptions depend on your state's version of the law and on your agency's facts; ask your counsel.

About Faradex. Faradex is a private AI workspace for small and mid-sized firms that handle confidential client work. Each firm gets its own Workspace on dedicated infrastructure in the United States. Files and conversations are held in memory and are gone when the Workspace is reset. AI model: Currently Opus via AWS Bedrock, more information is available on our website. AWS does not store prompts or responses, and model providers have no access to them. Pricing: from $120 a month, no seat minimum; see faradex.ai/pricing.